People are fascinating. I am biased towards the ones in auto racing. Let’s face it that is what I surround myself with so that is my frame of reference. Human beings are by far, to me, the most interesting piece of the motorsports puzzle.
In any realm, it is people who make the spark and the interest. Politics can be a very dry and clinical topic to study. One can read about laws and policies and crave some caffeine product. But let’s read about how different people with varied beliefs interpret and practice our politics and then we have some interesting subject matter.
Religion falls into the same category. Pick up a textbook and read a few chapters written centuries ago regarding another civilization’s beliefs. Good readings if that is what you are into. However the attention commanding material in usually about how citizens can read the same book, yet come to multiple conclusions about the same written lesson.
Switch scenes to our favorite sport we all know and love and people provide the most captivating topics. Business and machinery help stir the NASCAR pot. Men and women add the spice and flavor.
Week after week, race after race, new chapters are written. No two are exactly alike. In 2009 two men stand head and shoulders above the crowd for attention. They command it from the time the race haulers enter speedway grounds late in the week, to the time those same haulers are making the long journey down a dark interstate back to some race shop after completing a weekend’s work.
And their time in the world’s critical crosshairs was not earned from what they might do, but from what they already have done. Both drivers have entered the zone of “what will happen this race?” because of what has already occurred.
Circumstances have brought Dale Earnhardt, Jr. to where he is today. He is a man with a tremendous namesake. Second and third generation athletes live under a microscope and a heat lamp. Only unquestioned success brings relief. Ask a Manning brother.
Junior was brought into racing not just as a driver, but also as a son. He was a late model racer with a team his father owned. He was employed as a then-Busch Series driver by a team his father owned. He was brought to the Cup level with a team his father owned. And the day after Dale Earnhardt died was, very sadly, the news story that garnered the sport the most attention it ever received.
Front-page headlines about the Earnhardt passing were carried in newspapers that absolutely ignored auto racing. NASCAR’s most recognizable name was gone. Millions of fans and non-fans mourned the loss. This man was also a father. And one of his sons was left to carry the sport’s torch whether he was ready or not.
“Big E” was the guy who was introduced in pre-race ceremonies and nobody in the grandstand was using the seat they paid for. Some cheered. Others booed. All reacted. His presence was enormous.
Junior’s Nationwide resume shows two championships and twenty-two race wins. The Cup series’ victory lane has had him as the guest of honor on eighteen occasions. He resigned from Dale Earnhardt Incorporated at the 2007 season’s conclusion.
His driving tenure for Hendrick Motorsports began in 2008, arguably Sprint Cup racing’s strongest team. The championship car has come from Hendrick’s effort the past three consecutive years and eight times total since Jeff Gordon’s initial crown in 1995.
Now Junior has his best chance for success being with a quality racing team. He also is under more scrutiny than ever for the same reason, being with a quality racing team. So far in 2009 Earnhardt’s three stable mates have won races and are within the top ten in the title standings. The number eighty-eight stands out for its lack of performance compared to the five, twenty-four and forty-eight.
A recent crew chief change has legions of Dale’s fans chopping at the bit for a strong on-track improvement. Junior Nation’s large membership has had their patience tested.
If any of the above details were not part of the story, Dale would not be the center of attention that he is.
Kyle Busch entered the sport with another famous last name. Busch’s older brother Kurt entered NASCAR’s Truck Series in 2000. His move was quick to the Sprint Cup Series, entering events later that same year. He won the tour’s championship in 2004 and was regarded as a top driving talent. His attitude and personality did not endear himself to fans in the same matter as the third generation Earnhardt racer. Kurt had his collection of followers, and his detractors.
Guilt by association was what Kyle had to deal with from the people who did not like his older brother. There were some that took an anti-Kyle stance prior to his ever turning an upper level NASCAR wheel. His full time Sprint Cup career began in 2005 with the Hendrick organization.
Some of his attitude and behavior endeared him to his following of fans. It alienated him to others. The younger Busch brother’s driving talent became evident to everyone who watched him closely.
His personality comes out and appears in bright lights most weekends. Controversial moments have drawn battle lines between Busch supporters and Busch bashers. “Rowdy” has made comments after near wins that criticize his crew and other drivers, whomever he feels negatively impacted the victory effort. He does not bite his tongue and says what he thinks.
There are observers who praise the fact that a Sprint Cup driver actually gives his opinion and shows emotion, and not just rattles off sponsors and gives a sound bite whenever a microphone is put in front of him. Others jump to the other side of the fence and do not like Kyle’s style or substance. Witness the differing opinions after the recent Nashville Nationwide Series guitar-smashing incident.
The cherry on the cake that intertwines the two drivers is the fact that Rick Hendrick had Kyle Busch driving in his group. They agreed to part company and move on to other relationships. Busch filled a seat with Joe Gibbs Racing. The driver chosen to move under the HMS driver umbrella was Dale Earnhardt Jr. It reads a little like a “Seinfeld” episode, where random occurrences often are tied together at the conclusion of the show.
Auto racing trade paper op-ed pages and radio call in shows have three topics every week. Dale Earnhardt Jr., Kyle Busch, and whatever actually happened on the speedway. The first two have their fans and detractors wound up. Plenty are eager to wave the flag and cheer, or look for the opening to knock the legs out from either.
Something pretty strong has to happen to steal a piece of the fan’s debate. And it has at times. Carl Long’s penalty is a good example. Carl Edward’s spectacular crash at the spring Talladega race is another. But they are only temporary diversions. Eventually the hot topics come back around to our two lead characters.
This article is part of that phenomenon. We listen to the fans and watch what happens on the racetrack. There is no escaping the bench racing topics that keep coming up. I wonder what big story will come up that will eventually displace our current discussions? I know I will really enjoy watching. Racing has lots of characters and lots of stories waiting to happen. I can’t wait.




{ 16 comments… read them below or add one }
This is a well written effort. A rivalry is something that NASCAR has needed for some time now. A Kyle-Dale rivalry would have all of the elements. The good guy vs. bad guy, Chevy vs. Toyota, Hendrick vs Gibbs (Super Bowlish).
For it to happen though Dale has got to step up his program big time. His case may be that that a self imposed pressure to perform may be holding him back. Then again he may not be the talent that alot of fans think he is and may not be up to the challenge to compete with Kyle. Most everyone I talk to agrees that Kyle may be the best driver up there and is the only one creating any excitement in Cup racing. It’s going to kill alot of people but the comparisons to Dale Earhardt are inevitable. Junior’s fan want the comparison to be between Dale and Junior and it is not going to happen.
Al Torney, are you actually comparing Kyle Busch to Dale Earnhardt???? How long have you been following racing? Did you ever see dale Earnhardt drive a race car? You have got to be kidding me! I just cannot believe all the “new” NASCAR fans that actually say stuff like this!
Probably the most unbiased and intelligent article on this subject I have read.
“Unbiased” and “intelligent” are not two words easily associated with this debate. This issue is not about two NASCAR drivers. It’s about emotion vs fact, preconditioning vs independent thought, and, with apologies to the President, hope vs reality.
Have a Baptist read the Koran and then ask him if he has changed his belief. NOT GONNA HAPPEN. Why? Because he isn’t going to read it in the first place. If you already believe in one religion, you are going to refuse learning about another……..the devil’s temptation, and all.
Ask an Earnhardt Jr. fan to look at the head-to-head results of the Busch vs Earnhardt Jr. battles. NOT GONNA HAPPEN. Why? Because facts are irrelevent in an emotional debate. Earnhardt is the most popular driver in NASCAR because his fans were preconditioned to be fans through well known events. Busch seems to garner most of his fan base from people who appreciate actual results, and have found an icon to stand in the face of the ever tightning grip of the sport by the France family.
Oddly, NASCAR and the France family are the ones that ultimately benefit from the Rowdy/Jr fracas. With declining sponsorship money, declining attendence, and declining TV ratings, where would NASCAR really be without this emotion-laden cat fight?
At the end of the day, you really can’t ignore the facts. Given the best equiptment, best engineering, best fan support, and an altruistic owner, Earnhardt has proven that he is, at best, an average race car driver. Nothing wrong with that – there are dozens of them out there on the track with him. But, in the end, you have to call it what it is.
The so called Busch/Earnhardt rivalry so far has been one sided with all the rivalry on the Busch side. Jr does not seem to be the type of person who fights with others. Just tries to do his job. I for one have never compared anyone with Dale Sr. As far as I am concerned, there will always be only one Dale Sr. He was unique. I don’t believe Jr compares himself to his father, the media seems to be good at that. I think Dale Jr just wants to drive good and win races. Look at Mark Martin who has not won a championship. In my opinion, he is a better driver than most especially young punk Busch. It takes more than driving a race car to be a good all around driver. It is called class, sportmanship and respect for others that make the difference. Good article overall.
Great article on this most fascinating phenominon. There are two big reasons why fans like drivers (probably more than two, but these are the ones at work in this case)… They like them because they produce wins, or because they like them as a person. And in this case, we have one guy who is producing wins but has a lousy personality, and one guy who has a great personna, but isn’t producing wins right now. And you, as a fan, are on one side of the fence or the other. Imagine what will happen when these two men even themselves out… when Kyle’s performance levels out to equal his personality (stinks) and when Junior’s performance level equals his personality. (Fantastic.) Some think this will never happen, but to ponder the possibility is an interesting muse. We all know what would happen. One will rise like the sun, the other will sink like a rock in a pond.
And… You CANNOT compare Kyle to Dale Sr… Dale had so much more going for him. KyBu is more of a Darrell Waltrip.
Thanks for writing this, it was a great read!
I got the chance to see Dale Jr. race late models at Myrtle Beach speedway and could tell from the 1st time I saw him drive that he was a different kind of driver than his father. That is O.K. Before Big E died, he and Jr. actually had completely different fan bases. They really did. After the tragic finish to that 500 Jr. got most of his fathers fans added to his. They are a very loyal bunch and that is O.K. too. Kyle Busch had almost no fans when he signed with Hendrick, some of which was guilt by association because of his unpopular brother. I personally like Kurt more than Kyle and always have. I could see that Kyle was actually more cocky than Kurt. Kyle has added fans because of winning but has angered not only Jr. nation but most fans of other drivers because of his persistant bad attitude. I am not part of the Jr. nation, I prefer Jeff Gordon and Carl Edwards but I like Jr. He seems like a down to earth guy. I wish he would win a few races to get everyone off his back. I really do not think Kyle Busch compares to Dale Sr. either. I saw big Dale work his majic at Bristol in person. He was amazing at that track. I do not think Busch can pull off what I saw Dale Sr. do. The only driver that can come close to that kind of skill at Bristol is Tony Stewart. Kyle Busch has talent but Jeff Gordon, Tony Stewart, Carl Edwards and many others do also. Dale Jr. has a good personality and others do also, but Jr. has more talent than Kyle has likability. Just my thoughts. This is another great debate subject. Good job Jim.
You know what’s funny? After all that debate over manufacturer’’s? Almost all my favorites drive Bowties. It’s funny what you can learn by a guy’s favorite driver. Since I just have my “fan” hat on todya- I reveal my favoritesas Jeff Gordon, Carl Edwards, Bobby Labonte, Mark Martin and Junior. There’s not a ton of it, but if you think about it, it’s not hard to find a certain common denominator among them all.
Now what’s interesting to me is that you find another cross-section fans , who if they like Kyle, they also TEND TO (I’m generalizing here) like Smoke, Kevin Harvick and maybe even Robby Gordon.
Good article. As far as I’m concerned there’s room for all of them in NASCAR.
That is very interesting. The funny thing is I like all your favorite drivers and do not like Kyle Busch, Kevin Harvick or Robby Gordon. I must admit though, that I do like Smoke. His talent seems to outweigh the other stuff to me but the others on that list not so much.
Nice article. I’ve wondered if it’s more of a perceived rivalry though. Jr. doesn’t seem to care or acknowledge the rivalry. I think he’s too concerned about his Nationwide team, his club in Charlotte, and his drinkin’ buddies to care. But I truly hope that all the Kyle bashers ‘love’ to hate him. The alternative is that they want him out of the sport and I can’t believe that they would want that. Nascar benefits from both of these drivers so Nascar would suffer without both of these drivers. Personally, when I see people throw stuff and cuss at Kyle Busch, I’d rather see him go to F1 where talent is actually appreciated.
Yes it has been told Kyle is out performing Jr. BUT as is often overlooked he didn’t do well at Hendrick. The best thing that ever happened to Kyle was that he was let go by Mr. H. So what does this tell us? Did Kyle all of a sudden learn how to drive? Or could it be that he is NOW with the right people to help him perform very well on the track? I submit it is the latter. Jr. will perform again as he has in the past, all it takes is the right people around him. Perhaps with Lance he now has that, but it is just as likely that he doesn’t. If it is that Lance isn’t the guy I only hope that Mr. H doesn’t sit on it for another season.
Once again I have found your column courtesy of Jayski. I find you among the top of the NASCAR writing crop. This is as others have pointed out among the best written peices on this subject. I have never been a big fan of JRs. But at the same time have to admire him for the way he handles his huge responceability as the golden boy of NASCAR. It is a shame his talent will never live up to the huge pressure put apon him by his legion of fans. Since whatever Idiot decided to seperate him from Eury Sr his winning ways have been sparce at best. Sadly I just don’t feel he has what it takes to tell his crew how to keep the new car drivable during an entire race. and that will keep him from winning to many more races
Now for Kyle. Kyle is a race car driver. Born to drive cars fast. The biggest talent ever to hit the NASCAR circut.
Someday when all the fans in JR nation stop looking up at their hero on his pedestal and get tired of worshiping someone running in the middle of the pack because of his name. they will all agree. Win lose or draw I love to listen to the fire in Kyle, instead of the mumbling interviews of JR so craved by the media
Lori Anderson needs to stop drinking the kool aid. Jr is not a better driver than Busch and the win tally proves that. This will never be a rivalry until Jr can run up front weekend and weekout. Even with a terrible car this past weekend, Busch finished ahead of Jr. It is NOT the team, crew chief, or car. The problem lies with the mediocre driver in the 88.
Kyles rein of terror will come to an end also, then what will be said, will all the Kyle lovers still be there by his side? Will the media take him apart as they have Jr? Remember Kyle fans “All Glory is Fleeting”.
Thanks Larry. Kyle fans know that “All Glory is Fleeting” but at least there is glory to fleet. I wish the same could be said about his ‘rival’.
Gary, do you really? Jr. had the “Glory” when shrub was still soiling his undies. Jr. will get his act together, I admit not as fast as even his detractors would want (so it seems). It’s all about chemistry, you have to have the “right” people, that’s whatl it takes. Kyle has that….now, he didn’t have it at Hendrick. How lucky he is to find the “right people” makes him look like superman….for now.
After reading through this article, I feel that I really need more information on the topic. Could you suggest some more resources please?
p.s. Year One is already on the Internet and you can watch it for free.