Tweaking The Chase…..

by John Chapman on September 9, 2010 · 9 comments

As I’ve said before, "Tweaking the chase, is like tweaking a Yugo. It will still be a Yugo". Anything can be made better, including Yugo’s, and the Chase. With the emphasis that NASCAR places on the Chase, for it to do anything like they want it to do, (so far it hasn’t) some changes are needed.

Unlike stick and ball sports, NASCAR’s playoff involves all the teams, not just the contenders. That’s one of it’s inherent weaknesses. I’ve read countless variations on the theme that anyone who wins a race should be included. While I do favor the bonus points for winning, I can’t really buy into letting all winners in. The Chase is, after all, supposed to crown a season champion. Maybe, this being NASCAR- and NASCAR, being all about money- teams who have unused bonus points, like Jamie Mac, Juan,
or David Reutimann could sell them. You know like they do to manipulate the top 35 rule. Oops, sorry! my cynicism crept in, and I was trying so hard.

I do favor giving more weight to wins, but I still think it should be the whole package. I hate seeing multi winners, like Matt Kenseth last year, and Jamie not make it in, but if you’re good enough to be a multiple winner, then you should be good enough to put the rest of the package together.

One thing I do feel strongly about is that the regular or- as I like to call it- the pre-season winner deserves more consideration. I personally feel that he should start tied with the top bonus point man. As it stands, being the regular season leader counts for nothing. Just a further de-valuation of the regular season.

To give weight to race wins, (as well as regular season points leader) these bonus points need to carry more weight.
Remember, this whole Chase thingy came about because Matt won the championship in 2003 with only one win. A totally bogus reason, but the reason nevertheless. How’s it going to play if a winless team should hit on something, and win it all with a string of top 2-5 finishes? Not likely, but possible.

The Chase field already get their points re-set to start the Chase. Even with the re-set, they’re still racing the entire field for points.
Meaning that if a Chaser were to either break, or wreck,  before the
start and park teams do their thing. They’d get 34 points while the winner could get 190, as the Chasers are not racing the entire field for the Championship. Why make them race the field for points? They should have a point system that is only impacted by how they finish In relation to the other Chasers. To make winning carry more weight, how about something like 12 points for a Chase winner, graduated down to six for seventh, with everyone eighth through twelfth, getting five. To gain the top point total, a Chaser would not have to win the race. Only finish ahead of the other Chasers. Although I expect most, if not all races to be won by Chasers.
Under this system, the rest of the field is removed from the points equation.

To reflect the reduced points, I think three bonus points rather than ten. At three, four season wins, would equal a Chase win.
Under this system, J.J., Denny, and Kevin, as the season point leader, would start the Chase with a big leg up, but I think that’s not a bad thing. Under this scenario, a winless team would have to catch fire, rather than merely get hot. To catch the teams who got it done during the regular season.

On the other side of that coin, a Chaser who breaks a motor or wrecks, in the Chase, and finishes thirty-eighth, or so isn’t completely buried. This should keep the Chase field tightened up. Giving a better opportunity for the kind of  Chase NASCAR needs.
The idea of some sort of elimination has been mentioned, (even by me, if you were paying attention) but I was making fun of it at the time. I’m trying to be as serious as I ever get now. The elimination thing seems like just another contrivance in an already contrived situation. We all know that the bottom half of the Chase field have little, or no realistic chance of winning the thing. The Earnhardt/Gordon, expansion from 10 to 12 practically guaranteed this. Chase teams earned their way in, and I think they deserve the attention and sponsor exposure that goes with it for the entire Chase.

As it is, teams missing the Chase, still get to race, but it can’t be fun, being relegated to "field filler" status. Having to tip toe around the Chase teams. To me that’s really the fatal flaw in the Chase.
If you remember the first one in 2004, if Kurt had lost his wheel 50 feet further down the track, Johnson would have won  five of them. I’m not saying that JJ is not a great, or deserving champion.  If we had no chase he still would have probably won some championships during this stretch, but I doubt it would have been four.

As long as we have the Chase, it needs to do at least two important things: it needs to generate some renewed fan interest. At a time when fans are a little jaded, and distractions (like football) are intruding. Probably most important, at least to me, is that it crown a deserving champion. Come on NASCAR, make your tweaks, and give us a Chase that does this, and I’ll find a new horse to ride. Until then,…… well you get the idea.-

{ 9 comments }

Big 10 Driver Rankings

by Jim on September 8, 2010 · 0 comments

“It’s a marathon, not sprint.” What we see happening right now is a reminder that this adage is certainly true of a NASCAR Cup season.

It’s interesting to see the trends in place, and there we see another adage that applies: “The more something changes, the more it stays the same,” with some some drivers catching fire that we haven’t seen up front for a while.

THE BIG TEN

10. Jeff Gordon- (Down from #7)- Just edges out Matt Kenseth based on a slightly better average over the last fives races, and that’s all. The funny part is this guy is second in points, but his bar is set so high, we’re talking about his season like it’s disaster. Funny what winning- or the lack of it- does.

9. Juan Pablo Montoya- (Holding at #9)- Take a look at his last four races. The man has been downright phenomenal. We would be talking about the Colombian Comet is a whole different light if it weren’t so deep in the season. Seven DNFs is a hard defecit to overcome.

8. Clint Bowyer- (RE-ENTRY)- I give the man props. He needed a good day and he got it at Atlanta. We see flashes of what he can do, he just needs a little more of it.

7. Jeff Burton- (Up from #8)- A poor man’s Mark Martin. You don’t get where Burton does without talent, there just isn’t enough of the “wow” factor to get over the hump. The man needs a win. Of course, I could easily see Burton winning at one of the short tracks, or at Charlotte. Could be a stealth candidate, you never know. 

6. Kurt Busch- (Holing at #6)- You know what I love about this guy, he’s a fighter. What makes what Busch does even more impressive is the lack of anything to draw from in terms of teammates or any real allies. Stewart has a list of buddies a mile long. Edwards and Kyle have their teammates. What Johnson has almost borders on a mafia. Kurt has Kurt (well, o.k., he has Penske, which isn’t chopped liver)….and he competes well with it.

5. Jimmie Johnson- (RE-ENTRY)- I told you he wouldn’t stay down long, but then again, you probably didn’t need much convincing. The air of invincibility is gone, but all the ingredients that made him a champion are still there. From where I sit, I think the competition finally caught up.

4. Carl Edwards- (Down a spot from #3)- He didn’t do anything wrong, I’m not busting on him, for anything other than the fact that unlike the drivers ranked ahead of him, Edwards hasn’t won yet. Methinks that will be rectified before the year is out. I don’t even think a championship run is out of the question.

3. Tony Stewart- (Up two spots from #5)- ‘Round these parts, wins matter more. In Stewart’s case, more will follow. Like Gordon, and most other champions, Stewart is a threat to win anywhere. In a wide open chase, Smoke has to be thought of as one of the favorites. If there ever was anything wrong at Stewart- Haas, it’s been corrected.

2. Kyle Busch- (Holding at #2)- Forget for a moment what you think of him personality-wise. Personally, I think Kyle Busch is the biggest chap-ass in NASCAR, and that’s saying something, given the competition. It’s not how he drives, it’s how he treats people when he’s not going well that gets me. I couldn’t work for him. That said, The talent to rebound from adversity and wind his way through the field is undeniable. You people who hate him better get used to him. We’re going to see a lot of his mug for years to come.

1. Kevin Harvick- (Hanging on at #1)- While tempting to award this spot in the rankings to Stewart, Busch or even Cousin Carl, Harvick has earned the right to hold on to it for his overall body of 2010 work, and the fact his bum finish had more to do with bum tires than bum strategy. Let’s also acknowledge there is little incentive to really push harder at this point for the bonus points a win gets you. There’s no catching Hamlin or Johnson at this juncture.

FALLING OFF THE PACE

Greg Biffle took a hard hit with a 36th in the “A-T-L,” but his prior results give him wiggle room in the standings that matter….for teammate Matt Kenseth it’s another case of not being real bad, or being real good, either.

DISTANT THUNDER

Denny Hamlin gets props for putting on a good face, but it can’t be helping his confidence to go limping into the Chase like this….I wonder if Ryan Newman is carrying around a Bowyer voodoo doll? He’s right on the cusp of some really good things, but can’t seem to get a sustained run going…if Jamie McMurray’s season were an amusement ride, you’d need Dramamine for it…Martin Truex, Jr. is offering boss Michael Waltrip better results than Waltrip could get. He’s quietly running more often and more closely with solid top 15 guy David Reutimann. Anyone seen Mark Martin?

{ 0 comments }

Witnessing Wilkesboro’s Rising

by Patrick Reynolds on September 7, 2010 · 4 comments

When the Labor Day weekend brings forth gorgeous weather, barely any trace of clouds, a Carolina blue sky, and temperature in the 80s, that can be deemed a perfect day. Thousands will agree not because of the weather conditions. But because the roar of competing stock car engines again traveled through the hills of Wilkes County once known for legendary moonshine runners.

There has been activity at North Wilkesboro Speedway in recent times. Tractor pulls, video and movie shoots, racecar testing, and bicycles have all seen time on the track’s grounds. But this day was about the heart and soul of a short track in the Carolina Hills. North Wilkesboro Speedway was again hosting stock car racing again.

Speedway Associates is the group operating the five-eighths mile oval. Group pointman Alton McBride is currently working with a three-year lease and hosted Limited Late Models, a four-cylinder Stadium Stock class, Allison Legacy Series machines, and Super Late Models sanctioned by the Pro All Star Series.

The vast permanent grandstands hold around 40,000 spectators, which was filled in the Winston Cup days. But this day was about a rebirth, not superstar millionaires and their jets. A good crowd showed up for the program presented. McBride conservatively put the number around 6,000 to 7,000 including the infield pits and everyone on the grounds.

All ears intently listened to the invocation. Thousands stood silently at attention for the singing of our National Anthem. And then for the first time since 1996, the most famous words in auto racing were announced for competitive stock car racing. North Wilkesboro Speedway’s heart started beating. Its lungs were pumping oxygen. Life was reborn.

Bobby and Donnie Allison gave the command to start engines and the hair stood up on the back of my neck. A shiver ran through my shoulder blades. There were goose bumps on my arms. The crowd clapped their hands, let out war whoops, smiled, nodded, and looked at each other with approval and a sense of triumph and victory.

The afternoon’s first race was the Limited Late Models. Winner Mack Little’s voice cracked on the front stretch during his interview over the PA system. In tech inspection Little wore a constant smile, flushed cheeks and was beaming with honor over being the winner. He appreciated where he was and what he just did.

The elevator hoisted its first car since Jeff Gordon in 1996 to winner’s circle on top of the infield press box. Little’s car took the vertical ride on a device that started working about a week prior to the opening stock car race. And maintenance started about three months ago. McBride was proudly determined to have the signature elevator working no matter what.

Michael Tucker won the Stadium Stock four-cylinder race. Gus Dean claimed the Allison Legacy Series feature. Then the stage was set for the PASS 200.

Well known motorsports names graced the raceway on this warm, sunny and historic afternoon. Time between races provided fine opportunities to meet racing veterans.

I was fortunate enough to chat with racing photographer David Allio. He shared stories about shooting past races here and around the country.

Steve Post from Motor Racing Network told a tale about being one of the last people leaving the speedway in 1996. He was parked in a lot outside of turn three. It was late Sunday evening and he and his friends were still enjoying the day. Security eventually came over and told them to go home. He doesn’t make a claim that he literally locked the gates but figures he was one of the last ever people to leave the grounds. At least within a few hundred.

The day was complete with a presence most tracks can claim. A little kid behind the flagstand on the grandstand side waving his personal set of flags.

Walking around the pit area as the Super Late Model finale was being lined up, a sense of pride was felt amongst everyone in both the garage and grandstand sides. The grassroots atmosphere also had its hold on the pit area. A total of only 10 stacker trailers were parked in the PASS garage. Pickup trucks towed most of the racing equipment this weekend.

Returning to the press box for the main event, I took note of the wood paneling and carpeting that would make Mike and Carol Brady proud. It is just part of the nice nostalgic atmosphere here.

Following a formation grid and the firing of engines, racing writer Mike Neff said, “14 years I’ve been waiting for this moment I can’t believe it.” He then pumped both fists high in the air and yelled out a genuinely joyous “Woo-Hoo” when the featured event got the green flag and the field barreled into turn one for the first of 200 times. For a few moments at least he was not a journalist, but an excited race fan.

McBride was speaking to a group during the PASS parade laps. “We are making history here,” he said as the pace car pulled off. The coincidental timing of his remarks was remarkable.

Tire eating pavement saw Jody Lavender and Chase Elliott slide their cars off many a corner while battling for the lead during a long green flag run. The race formed into two chapters, the first half dominance by Lavender and the second half dominance by Elliott.

Long shadows covered the Wilkesboro frontstretch as the sun dropped a little lower in the sky. The afternoon turned later as did the race. Double checkered flags waved over Chase Elliott to end the day. Wilkesboro stock car racing was reborn. His father Bill won the very first Daytona 500 I ever witnessed in person. But Chase accomplished something dad never could. He put an Elliott in victory lane here.

The fans did not create a mad rush for the exits and generate a traffic jam right after the final checkered. Many stayed just to absorb the day and remember the moments in time that breathed life into a treasured racetrack. Thousands smiled, reflected, cheered, hugged and were happy that they watched racing again at this Speedway. Some filed onto the track surface to get a look at a new generation of driving heroes. A few took one last swipe of the concessions for the day. Others just sat in those same shadows, enjoying their time in a grandstand seat.

“There’s a lot of happy people down there,” said Wilkesboro media representative Deb Williams as we looked from high atop the grandstands. And that statement didn’t just describe the day’s race winners. Well said Deb, well said.

(Patrick Reynolds is a former NASCAR team mechanic whoo hosts “Motorweek Live” Thursdays at 9pm ET. Listen at www.racersreunionradio.com)

{ 4 comments }